Pontoon Boat or Kayak for Fishing?

Thank you for reading our post, please rate this article at the end.

Last Updated on August 23, 2024 by Paul Clayton

Pontoon Boat or Kayak for Fishing?

When considering a pontoon boat or kayak for fishing, it’s essential to understand the unique features and benefits each offers anglers. Both have specialized uses in the fishing community, catering to different preferences and fishing environments.

Key Takeaway

The article discusses the pros and cons of pontoon boats and fishing kayaks to help you decide which is better for your fishing needs.

Summary

• • Pontoon boats are stable, comfortable, and affordable. Due to their excellent stability, they are ideal for fly-fishing in calm or moving waters and provide ample space for storage and companions. However, they are not very maneuverable and are not recommended for use in rough waters or narrow spaces.
  • Fishing kayaks are stealthy and efficient, allowing you to access shallow and narrow waters. They come in various subtypes to suit your preference, such as sit-on-top or sit-inside kayaks. However, compared to pontoon boats, fishing kayaks can be less stable and require more physical activity.

If you are a low-key angler looking to improve your game, investing in a high-quality fishing boat is the best way to begin.

Although there are various boats, pontoons, and kayaks are the two most popular boats that many anglers prefer.

A pontoon boat or kayak for fishing purposes is designed uniquely and differs from its recreational counterparts. Choosing a vessel that best suits your fishing style can be daunting. But don’t worry—I am here to help you.

This article will help you better understand both types of boats so you can get their details before making a purchase. Keep reading!

Characteristics of Fishing Pontoon Boats

Fishing pontoons are inflatable boats eight to thirteen feet long and 48 to 56 inches wide. They consist of two air bladders connected by either a metal frame or a curved air bladder (in the case of frameless pontoons).

Inflatable pontoons are tough, abrasion-free PVC materials to withstand extreme water temperatures. Fishing pontoons are designed for solo fishing. These boats usually have one seat on top of the metal frame or built-in for the frameless variety.

They are available in four main types: standard one-person, two-person, backpackable, and float hybrid pontoons.

Advantages of Pontoon Boats

Pontoon boats can be your personal favorites when going solo. Here are some of the reasons:

• Best for Fly-fishing

Pontoons are designed specifically for fly-fishing. They provide the perfect platform for casting in both moving and calm waters.

You can navigate small waterways, as these boats have excellent stability due to their large air bladders, which increase their buoyancy in water.

Also, your visual range increases as you sit high up in the water in this typical boat. Fishing pontoons have all the necessary storage pockets and features that enable anglers to float and fish easily.

• Highly Portable

Regarding portability, an inflatable pontoon boat can easily be broken down to fit in your car’s trunk and reassembled in 10 to 15 minutes.

Storing it isn’t a hassle, as it can be deflated and stored in the back of your garage without occupying too much space.

• Comfortable

If you don’t want to paddle your inflatable pontoon, you can motorize it and launch it in the water quickly.

In addition, this boat allows you to stay dry, carry a large amount of fishing gear, and bring food on your trip, thanks to its large storage capacity of 350-400 lbs.

In a two-person inflatable pontoon, you can always enjoy your fishing expedition with some company.

• Economical

A fishing pontoon’s price tag will have you double-checking it. These boats are cheap, with prices as low as $100 – $300. Despite being so inexpensive, they are highly durable.

Disadvantages of Pontoon Boats

Since no boat is ever perfect, fishing pontoon boats have a few drawbacks. The following are a few:

• Not Versatile

You may think a pontoon boat or kayak is quite similar in terms of maneuverability for fishing in freshwaters, but this is far from the truth.

Due to its bulky structure, paddling your inflatable through debris, narrow inlets, and fallen trees is almost impossible, restricting you from fishing in open areas only.

Furthermore, remember never to take your inflatable pontoon into the ocean, as it is not designed to handle rough waters.

• Less Efficient

Due to the pontoon’s chunky structure, you may need to paddle longer to reach your favorite fishing spot.

Moreover, inflating a pontoon requires close monitoring as over or under-inflation can build up pressure that strains the material.

Characteristics of Fishing Kayaks

A fishing kayak is a narrow, sleek boat resembling a canoe. On average, they are 13 feet long and 36 inches wide. Kayaks are made of fiberglass or polyethylene and are pretty sturdy.

They usually have four hull designs: rounded, V-hull, flat, and pontoon, each suitable for different water types.

In addition, fishing kayaks are available in 6 subtypes: sit-on-top, sit-inside, pedal-drive, tandem, inflatable, or motorized kayaks.

In general, anglers prefer sit-on-top fishing kayaks.

Advantages of Fishing Kayaks

Investing in a fishing kayak will satisfy you whenever you take it out on the waters. Here are some of its benefits:

• Good Stealth

A fishing kayak provides excellent stealth (the ability to sneak up on wary fish without scaring them). You can quietly crawl your way up on fish, thanks to the narrow design of a kayak that does not make a substantial underwater shadow.

A kayak will let you gently paddle to a fishing spot and reel in plenty of fish.

• Efficient and Versatile

Fishing kayaks are masters of efficiency. You can paddle swiftly in shallow waters and squeeze through narrow spaces without damaging it.

Since they sit low in the water, their wind resistance decreases, making them highly versatile and suitable for use in both salt and freshwater.

Disadvantages of Fishing Kayaks

Like any other boat, fishing kayaks also have a few negative points. Some of them are:

• Costly

Fishing kayaks can be expensive, ranging from $300 to $1100 and even higher, depending on how you accessorize them.

• Less Portable

Kayaks are heavy and require a trailer for transportation. They are also challenging to store as long vessels cannot deflate and take up plenty of storage space.

Pontoon Boat or Kayak for Fishing: A Quick Contrast

Fishing pontoon boats are budget-friendly, highly portable, secure, and comfortable fishing vessels suitable for fun, lazy fishing, primarily recreational fly-fishing.

In contrast, kayaks are speedy, sporty, and highly efficient. These flexible watercraft are meant for serious fishing, such as competing in fishing tournaments and bass fishing.

FAQs

Which is better for beginners, a pontoon boat or a kayak?

Pontoon boats are generally better for beginners due to their stability and ease of use. They offer a safer platform, reducing the risk of tipping. Kayaks can be challenging for those new to paddling and balancing, though wider models provide more stability.

Can I fish in shallow waters with a pontoon boat?

While pontoon boats are stable, their size limits access to shallow waters. They are better suited for open lakes and rivers. Kayaks excel in shallow and confined fishing spots with their shallow draft and maneuverability.

How much maintenance do pontoon boats require compared to kayaks?

Pontoon boats require more maintenance, including engine upkeep, cleaning, and storage care. They also involve higher fuel costs and potential insurance. Kayaks require minimal maintenance, primarily cleaning and minor repairs, making them cost-effective.

Are kayaks suitable for extended fishing trips?

Kayaks can be used for extended fishing trips but offer less comfort and storage than pontoon boats. Pontoons provide spacious decks, comfortable seating, and amenities, making them better suited for extended outings with multiple anglers and gear.

What type of water conditions are best for kayaks?

Kayaks are ideal for calm and shallow waters, narrow channels, and areas with heavy vegetation. Their maneuverability allows access to spots larger boats can’t reach. They are less suitable for rough waters, where pontoon boats offer more stability.

Do pontoon boats disturb fish more than kayaks?

Being larger and motorized, Pontoon boats can create more noise and disturbance in the water, potentially scaring fish away. Powered by paddles, Kayaks are quieter and stealthier, allowing anglers to approach fish with minimal disruption.

What are the storage options for each?

Kayaks are compact and can be stored in garages, sheds, or indoors. They are easy to transport on car roofs. Pontoon boats require larger storage spaces, such as boat docks or trailers, and need more effort for transportation and storage.

What is a pontoon boat used for?

Pontoons are primarily designed for freshwater use and offer a versatile platform for various activities. Their spacious decks make them perfect for socializing, allowing families and friends to gather comfortably.

Additionally, pontoon boats are well-suited for recreational activities such as waterskiing and fishing, providing ample space for equipment and movement.

What type of kayak is best for fishing?

Sit-on-top kayaks are generally recommended for novice paddlers due to their inherent stability and ease of re-entry if capsized. These kayaks are designed to be virtually unsinkable, providing a safer experience for beginners.

Conversely, more experienced kayakers may prefer longer sit-in kayaks, which offer a lower center of gravity and enhanced stability in rough waters.

The design of sit-in kayaks allows them to handle challenging conditions more effectively, making them suitable for seasoned anglers who want to navigate diverse aquatic environments.

Summary

When deciding between a pontoon boat or kayak for fishing, both options offer distinct advantages tailored to different fishing experiences.

A pontoon boat provides substantial comfort and space, making it ideal for anglers who need ample room for gear and companions. Its excellent stability significantly reduces the risk of accidents, allowing for a secure fishing environment.

Additionally, its versatility makes it suitable for various water bodies and fishing techniques. However, a pontoon boat’s higher initial and ongoing costs can be a deterrent for some.

On the other hand, a kayak stands out as a budget-friendly option with minimal upkeep. Its smaller size allows it to navigate shallow and narrow waters that are typically inaccessible to larger boats, providing access to secluded fishing spots.

The stealthy nature of a kayak’s quiet operation enables anglers to approach fish without startling them. Moreover, using a kayak combines physical activity with fishing, offering an engaging workout that enhances the overall experience.

Choosing between a Pontoon Boat or Kayak for Fishing depends on individual preferences and priorities, weighing factors such as comfort, cost, accessibility, and personal fitness goals.

Home page
Back to the top of the page