Pontoon Boat or Fishing Boat? Make The Right Choice

Thank you for reading our post, please rate this article at the end.

Last Updated on August 23, 2024 by Paul Clayton

Pontoon Boat or Fishing Boat? Make The Right Choice

The dilemma of whether to buy a pontoon boat or a fishing boat is not easily solved. Several factors need to be considered while making the decision.

Key Takeaway

Choosing between a pontoon boat and a fishing boat depends on your primary purpose for using the boat.

Summary

• • Pontoon boats are ideal for recreational activities like cruising, swimming, and sunbathing. They offer spacious decks, comfortable seating, and stability.
  • Fishing boats are designed specifically for fishing and prioritize features like rod holders, live wells, and casting platforms. They may be less spacious and comfortable than pontoon boats.
  • Consider your intended use, budget, and desired features when deciding.

Fishing boats are designed specifically for fishing purposes. Pontoons are also a viable option for fishing, but they are not specifically designed for the same purpose.

You may be pondering the differences between these two boats. Which is better, and what are their pros and cons?

And all these types of questions. So, if you are confused about choosing a pontoon or a fishing boat, this article may help you.

The factors outlined in this article will help you comprehend and make the right choice. Now, without further ado, let’s dive into them.

Characteristics of Pontoons

Pontoons are easily identifiable by their flat tops. They offer a wide and spacious area for the passengers to move around in. Modern pontoons are luxurious and family-friendly. They are also known as ‘party boats.’

Pontoon boats consist of two canoes that allow them to be buoyant. Due to their significant buoyancy, pontoons are larger and can carry more people. Moreover, the length of the pontoon varies between 17 and 40 feet.

Pros:

• Comfort

If you prioritize comfort the most, a pontoon is the best boat option. With a pontoon, you will no longer have to sit on hardened steel or wood. Instead, the pontoon comes with luxurious sofas and comfy chairs.

Moreover, you are free to customize the pontoon’s deck furniture. The Pontoon also offers plenty of space, provided that few people are on board.

• Safety Advantage

The pontoon is among the safest boats in its league. Its design may not look lavish or extraordinary, but it is stable. Its low average speed and the high railings around it also make it a much safer option.

Pontoons have a wide turn radius, similar to those exasperating 18-wheelers. That is good, as it keeps you safe by preventing risky turns.

This wide turn radius prevents you from turning the boat on its side. Although pontoons are safe, you should always keep safety kits, such as life jackets.

• A Good Choice for Families With Kids

Kids like to play around and have fun, and they hate it when you make them sit in one place. Kids get easily bored on traditional fishing boats because they offer little.

However, on a pontoon, they will get enough room to jump off the couches, run, ride the tube, etc.

Unlike traditional boats, pontoons can hold up to 10 passengers at once. So, a pontoon is an excellent option to spend quality time with your kids on a boat.

Cons:

• Not for Rough Waters

Although a pontoon can be used in saltwater, taking it deep into the ocean might cause trouble.

When strong winds of the sea during bad weather conditions come into play, things can get terrible. They are not designed for harsh weather conditions.

Keep in mind that this only applies to bad weather or wind conditions. Otherwise, a pontoon is a safe option in normal conditions.

• Speed

A pontoon can not serve your purpose if all you want is speed. Pontoon boats are not for racing, and most cannot accelerate much. If high speed is what you are looking for, then you will surely be disappointed.

Characteristics of Fishing Boats

Fishing boats are specifically designed for catching fish. They have a V-shape structure with vells, gear storage, and trolling systems. You can use them for trolling or drift fishing.

Pros:

• Speed

When it comes to speed, fishing boats are undoubtedly faster than pontoons. Due to their agility, fishing boats can accelerate much faster than long and lavish boats.

Generally, these boats are relatively better equipped to handle rough and extreme weather conditions.

Due to their accelerated speed, fishing boats can quickly leave or reach areas densely populated by fish. With a fishing boat, you can cover a lot of water in less time.

• Ultimate Fishing Machine

Fishing boats are known for their ability to access all parts of the water. They can sneak through even the tiniest of nooks. A fishing trip can even last a day with a fishing boat.

Their mobility, immense power, and other features combined make it the ultimate fishing boat.

Cons:

• Not Spacious Enough

Unlike pontoons, fishing boats do not offer enough space to do fun activities comfortably. With more than four people on board, you might feel cramped. However, several types of fishing boats, like catamarans, are relatively larger.

But traditional fishing boats are usually 15-25 feet long. So if you want a family-friendly recreational fishing boat with enough space to roam around, a traditional fishing boat might not be the right choice.

However, they do offer storage for keeping fish.

• All You Can Do is Fishing! Nothing More

There are many dedicated anglers worldwide. But many prefer to have fun, play games, relax, and spend quality time on their fishing trips.

Unfortunately, most fishing boats do not offer such activities, and they do not have enough space either.

Therefore, fishing becomes dull for such people. But if you only want to catch fish, opting for a fishing boat will serve your purpose.

Factors To Consider When Choosing a Pontoon Boat or Fishing Boat

Purpose and Usage

Pontoon boats are versatile and designed for leisure activities like cruising, swimming, and hosting gatherings. They provide ample deck space and comfortable seating, often with amenities like grills and coolers.

Conversely, fishing boats are built specifically for angling. They feature specialized equipment like rod holders, live wells, and trolling motors, making them ideal for serious fishermen.

Size and Space

Due to their wide, flat decks, pontoon boats generally offer more space and can accommodate larger groups, making them perfect for family outings or parties on the water.

This spaciousness allows for easy movement and can include areas for sunbathing, dining, and even watersports.

While fishing boats vary in size, they often have a more compact and efficient layout. Their design maximizes functionality, with storage compartments for gear and bait.

A pontoon boat excels if space and comfort for multiple people are priorities. A fishing boat fits the bill if you need a streamlined, purpose-driven vessel.

Amenities and Comfort

Pontoon boats excel in offering amenities that enhance comfort and enjoyment. They often include plush seating, sound systems, sunshades, and even small kitchens or bars.

These features make them excellent for social gatherings and extended time on the water.

While sometimes equipped with basic comfort features, fishing boats prioritize practical angling needs. They include fish finders, bait prep stations, and tackle storage.

Maintenance and Durability

Maintenance and durability are crucial factors to consider. With their more straightforward design and often aluminum construction, Pontoon boats require less frequent maintenance and are relatively easy to clean.

Their flat surfaces and accessible components contribute to lower upkeep costs.

Fishing boats, especially those used in saltwater, demand more maintenance due to exposure to harsh conditions and complex systems.

Regular engine checks, hull inspections, and cleaning are necessary to ensure longevity.

Storage and Transport

Considering how you’ll store and transport your boat is essential.

Due to their size and shape, pontoon boats may require more substantial storage facilities and specialized trailers. Their wide beam can also make it more challenging to transport them on narrow roads.

Fishing boats, typically more streamlined and often smaller, are easier to trailer and store in standard garages or boat slips.

Pontoon Boat or Fishing Boat: Which is Better?

It’s tough to choose between a pontoon boat and a fishing boat. The choice solely depends on the passenger’s lifestyle and the boat’s purpose. However, this article can help us draw some conclusions.

When Pontoon Boat is the Best Choice

Pontoons are best for leisure fishers or families who want the best of both worlds. If you plan to invite your guests, what’s better than taking them on a pontoon ride?

When to Choose a Fishing Boat

This is the best option for dedicated anglers who only step onto the boat when confident of a great catch.

Related Questions

What is the best type of boat for fishing?

Many experienced anglers and marine enthusiasts recommend bay boats. These vessels are designed explicitly for coastal saltwater fishing and offer amateur and professional fishermen optimal features.

Bay boats are distinguished by their raised casting decks at the bow and stern, which provide an elevated vantage point for spotting and casting to fish.

This design feature significantly enhances the fishing experience by offering a clear line of sight and easier access to fish.

Furthermore, most bay boats are easily trailerable, with lengths typically ranging from 19 to 26 feet, making them a convenient option for those exploring different fishing locales.

Can a pontoon boat be used for fishing?

Many pontoon boats can be outfitted for fishing with accessories like rod holders and live wells. They provide ample space and comfort for casual fishing trips, though they lack the specialized features of dedicated fishing boats.

Are fishing boats suitable for family outings?

Fishing boats, especially those with dual-purpose designs, can be used for family outings. However, they may lack pontoon boats’ spacious comfort and amenities, making them less ideal for non-fishing activities.

Summary

Assessing your primary activities and preferences on the water is essential when considering whether a pontoon or fishing boat is the right choice for your aquatic adventures.

With its spacious layout and comfortable seating, a pontoon boat is ideally suited for leisure activities, family outings, and social gatherings.

Its stability and smooth ride make it a favorite among families looking for a safe and enjoyable experience on the water. On the other hand, a fishing boat is specifically designed to cater to the needs of anglers and fishing enthusiasts.

Equipped with functional seating and optimized features for fishing, it offers stability in rough waters. It is built for speed and agility, making it perfect for those who prioritize fishing activities over leisure cruising.

In summary, a pontoon boat is an ideal choice if you want to enjoy leisurely cruises, entertain friends and family, and prioritize comfort and space.

However, if you focus on fishing and require a boat that can navigate rough waters quickly and efficiently, a fishing boat is undoubtedly the better option.

Both types of boats offer distinct advantages tailored to different preferences and activities on the water.

Home page
Back to the top of the page